5'9" 230ish. Pretty stocky, but also dropping weight as I've been trying to be a lot more active lately (one of the main reasons I'm looking to get back into biking.) More off the path trails than anything. Kind of like what I used to like to do. I hear you on the price/quality point. I knew road bikes were gettiing up there. But I could never see myself paying 4k+ for some of the USED bikes I was seeing on pinkbike. I know you're not advocating I go that route, but im just wondering if those kind of bikes are really that great of a difference for a guy just trying to get back out there. lol I'm leaning towards something like the Treks you put up. I think I could live with the hardtail easier than something without a nice front suspension and/or disc brakes. Hell that's why my legs can bend, right?