This is more directed at Wil (Civicious). If I'm looking to spend $7-$12k on a newer car, what would be my best bet. I'm looking for Audi comfort, rear or all wheel, preferably manual, with at least 220hp. Creature comforts are a big plus. Reliability is fairly important. I know how to maintain my cars. I'd rather not have to pull the motor to do a timing belt (stupid Audi).
I really like the S4, but I already know how you feel about that. Any good suggestions?
I've considered E36 M3, AMG something maybe, etc?
You should be able to pick up an E46 M3 or an early 2000's AMG (CLK 55 or E55, non supercharged AMG v8) for under 12k. Any of those are great cars provided they've been taken care of.
If you want an Audi, get an Audi - but be prepared to do a good bit of work on it