manning has had a hall of fame running back and 2 hall of fame receivers play for him.
favre has not.
Edgerrin James is no HOF RB.
Harrison obviously yes, Wayne, not yet.
You could still take any of the guys with more than 1 ring too.
Montana, Aikman, Bradshaw, etc.
Brady has 3, and never had a great RB or WR when they won SB's.
If you play 20ish years like Farve, you're bound to put up big #'s. He played on a LOT of mediocre teams.