The Greatest Quarterback of ALL time

[get_nick]

blah, tried to post it but couldn't

his only real drawback is that he always seems to lose the big games, even in college. Still he could end up as the greatest ever or could flop out his ass the next ten years (see Kurt Warner). Either way it's to early in his career to tell

how is kurt warner a flop? he was bagging fucking grocerys when he was like 28 and went on to be a 2 time mvp and win a super bowl. that's the dumbest statement in this thread.

we need to figure out greatest first. everybody has a different definition. greatest - Definitions from Dictionary.com

by definition, i would have to say brett favre. he's a great leader, great stats, 3 time mvp and has won the big one. what else can you look for?

 

[B16RacerN2NR]

I am biased towards Troy Aikman I grew up watching him so he gets my vote...

But from the list, Brett Farve FTW

 

[Seany-izzle]

how is kurt warner a flop? he was bagging fucking grocerys when he was like 28 and went on to be a 2 time mvp and win a super bowl. that's the dumbest statement in this thread.

And what has he done since??? Then again, ther eis always Leaf

 

[get_nick]

And what has he done since??? Then again, ther eis always Leaf

it doesn't matter what he's done since. the fact that he worked his way from arena-european nfl-bagger-nfl is enough isn't it? you are never a flop if you win mvp. you might be inconsistent or injury prone, but never a flop. that is really bad.

 

[yorkiedad]

Greatest Quarterback of all time

If you mean professional football, it has to be Sammy Baugh!! He revolutionized the game. He's now 92 years old, and still holds records that haven't been broken. He played for the Redskins unitl the early 1950's before most of you were even born.

 

[Havok]

Kiss the rings, bitch! Joe Montana proved that he could win it all--again and again.

Marino was great, but not the best because people always go back to one thing--which Super Bowl did he play in/win? Oh yeah.

Fucked up, but it's life.

 

[totalburnout]

Steve Young isn't in there at all?

fuck you all.

 

[Havok]

Hah! Steve Young couldn't hold Joe Montana's jockstrap.

 

[totalburnout]

Hah! Steve Young couldn't hold Joe Montana's jockstrap.

Laughable.

Young and Farve battled year after year for the title of the best quarterback in the league until Young had about his 4th concussion.