i still like it better, and ive driven all three
the S2k and the Z4 3.0 (and Z3 as well) are pretty nice, i just CANNOT LIKE THE POOR MANS 911...CANNOT
The S2K is just so much more fun to drive. The steering is more responsive so is the throttle, and i love the sound of 9k...thinking about it right now is making me smile.
The Z4 has a great suspension setup, but its just lacking in the steering. Kinda numb if you ask me....which kinda kills the stiff suspension, doesnt it...
Porsche....just porsche....i havent driven a sports car made within the last 5 years with 5 gears or less. guess what...boxster sucks. the S is almost worth driving, but thats the only boxster that gets an almost. Even though the new boxsters have a 6 speed, it puts that car WAY out of the price range for that test. about 46k for a normal boxster with a 6spd...thats rediculous.
Im just ranting at this point. I hate the Boxsters...if ya go porsche you better have a cayenne or a 911 (maybe the cayman, but since there arent many to test drive, i cant tell you that)...
My vote woulda been the S2k. Sounds mean, revs to 9k all day, and i got brand loyalty like whoa.