The album honestly blew me away. I thought it was going to be a lame attempt to rekindle some of the musical awesomeness of the earlier albums. I was wrong, thank God.
Most of the songs are well produced, sound really good and move along at a good pace, with the typical solo and break down. A lot of songs have a Black Album/Ride the Lightning feel to them, and some sound closer to the country-ish Load and Reload.
But what surprised me the most was "The Unforgiven III". When I first saw the title, I laughed a little bit and figured they royally screwed up - but the song is actually amazing. "Suicide and Redemption" is a 8.xx minute instrumental that is kind of a throwback to "The Call of Ktulu", with good riffs, a lot of style changes and a good rhythm overall.
I'd give the album an 8.9 out of 10, simply because I hate "My Apocalypse", and the first three songs sort of run into each other. Otherwise, a great comeback after St. Anger.
And to be honest, but better production values, and maybe some better guitar work, St. Anger could actually be good. A lot of the songs have decent lyrics, but the absolute shit sound and lack of solos by Kirk kill everything.
But in the end, everyone can call Metallica sellouts - because they sell out every venue they play.