Philly, you did do it wrong, so I'm just going to ignore your turn for now, but feel free to keep playing. The way it works is that you pick one to kill, and one to save, and you add one to the number of the save, and take away one from the number of the kill. If a save reaches 15 then it goes down to the "Best Bands" list. If a kill reaches zero, then it gets eliminated and you put a new band up.
Pearl Jam - 7
Journey - 13 KILL
Alice in Chains - 5
Smashing Pumpkins - 5 SAVE (I know a lot of people hate them and their new album isn't so great, but they were absolutely epic back in the day; I still listen to their stuff on an almost daily basis)
Nirvana - 5
Best Bands:
Beastie Boys
Led Zeppelin
Metallica
Pink Floyd
RHCP